Lower Home Loan Repayments Don't Always Mean You're Saving Money
If someone offered to reduce your home loan repayments by $200 a month, you'd probably be pretty happy. After all, that's $2,400 a year back in your pocket, and with household budgets under pressure, every dollar counts.
But here's something that might surprise you. Lower home loan repayments don't necessarily mean you're saving that much money. In fact, depending on how your new loan is structured, you could end up paying more interest over the life of your mortgage, even with a lower interest rate.
It's one of the most commonly overlooked aspects of refinancing, and it's something worth understanding before deciding whether switching lenders is actually worthwhile.

A Lower Interest Rate Is Only Part of the Story
When comparing home loans, most people naturally focus on the interest rate. And why wouldn't they? A lower rate generally means less interest charged on the money you've borrowed, which sounds like an obvious win. However, the interest rate is only one part of the equation. Another important consideration is how long you have left to repay your mortgage.
Let's say you've been paying off your home loan for three years and have 27 years remaining. You find another lender offering a more competitive interest rate and decide to refinance, but the new loan is established over a fresh 30-year term. By doing this, you've effectively added another three years to your mortgage. Your repayments will likely decrease, partly because you're paying a lower interest rate, but also because you're spreading the outstanding balance over a longer period.
Now, there's nothing inherently wrong with that. Having lower monthly repayments can provide some much-needed breathing room, particularly if household expenses have increased. The important thing is understanding how much of that reduction comes from genuine interest savings and how much comes from extending the loan term.
Let's Look at a Realistic Refinancing Example
Imagine you have a $521,000 home loan with an interest rate of 6.54% and 27 years remaining. Another lender is offering you 6.24%, but with a new 30-year loan term.
Here's how the two loans compare.
Current Loan | New Loan | |
Loan balance | $521,000 | $521,000 |
Interest rate | 6.54% | 6.24% |
Loan term | 27 years | 30 years |
Monthly repayment | $3,429 | $3,204 |
At first glance, refinancing looks pretty attractive. Your monthly repayments would decrease by approximately $224, giving you almost $2,700 more cash available over the first year. If your new lender also charges $120 less in annual account fees, that's approximately $2,811 in improved household cash-flow. That's certainly nothing to sneeze at, but there's a difference between having more money available each month and actually saving that money.
So, How Much Are You Really Saving?
The interest rate difference between these two loans is 0.30%. On a $521,000 balance, that's approximately $1,563 in annual interest savings if the balance remained unchanged.
Of course, home loan balances generally reduce as repayments are made, so the actual interest saving over the first 12 months is a little different. Based on the repayment schedules for these two loans, the interest saving would be approximately $1,520. We also need to consider any ongoing account fees and the cost of refinancing. For this example, let's assume the new lender saves you $120 in annual fees, but switching loans costs $1,000.
First 12 months | Amount |
Interest saved | $1,520 |
Annual account fees saved | $120 |
Cost of refinancing | −$1,000 |
How much better off? | $640 |
Suddenly, that $2,811 improvement in annual cash-flow looks a little different, doesn't it?
The reason is that while you're making smaller repayments, you're also paying less off the actual loan balance each month. After 12 months, you'd still owe approximately $1,171 more on the refinanced loan than you would have owed if you'd stayed with your existing lender. In other words, you're keeping more money in your pocket each month, but you're also reducing your mortgage debt more slowly. Once you account for the difference in interest, fees and switching costs, the actual improvement in your financial position is approximately $640 over the first year.
That doesn't make refinancing a bad decision. It simply means the $2,811 reduction in payments shouldn't be confused with $2,811 in savings.
These figures are illustrative estimates based on principal and interest repayments, unchanged interest rates, no offset or additional repayments, and refinancing costs paid separately.
Does That Mean Refinancing Isn't Worth It?
Not at all. Refinancing can be an excellent financial decision, and there are plenty of reasons why changing lenders might make sense beyond simply securing a lower interest rate.
One important thing to remember is that refinancing doesn't automatically mean starting a new 30-year mortgage. In many cases, you can choose to refinance over the same remaining loan term, subject to lender policy and approval, and if your broker isn't giving you both options, they should be.
Using our example, if you have 27 years remaining on your current home loan, you could refinance to the lower 6.24% interest rate and keep the new loan term at 27 years. You'd still benefit from lower interest charges and reduced monthly repayments, without adding another three years to your mortgage. This is often an option worth considering if your goal is to save interest while staying on track to pay off your home loan within your original time frame.
Of course, you could also choose to extend the loan term to 30 years if reducing your monthly commitments is the priority. For some households, having an extra $200 or $300 available each month can make a meaningful difference to their budget. There's nothing necessarily wrong with that approach, provided you understand the longer-term implications.
Another option is to refinance at the lower interest rate but continue making the same repayments you were making before. Assuming your lender allows additional repayments, the difference would go towards reducing your loan balance faster, potentially saving even more interest and helping you become mortgage-free sooner.
The important thing is that refinancing gives you choices. You don't necessarily have to sacrifice your original repayment time-frame to benefit from a better interest rate, and you don't have to accept the minimum monthly repayment if your financial circumstances allow you to pay more. This is why I believe the structure of your home loan is just as important as the interest rate. Two loans with identical interest rates can produce very different financial outcomes depending on their terms, features and how you choose to make repayments.
Don't Forget the Cost of Changing Lenders
Another consideration that often gets overlooked is the upfront cost of refinancing. Depending on your existing loan and the lender you're moving to, there may be discharge fees, mortgage registration costs, settlement fees or application charges. Some lenders may also require a new valuation or charge ongoing package fees, while others occasionally offer cashback incentives to attract refinancing customers. If you're borrowing above certain loan-to-value thresholds, Lenders Mortgage Insurance may also be a consideration.
These costs can make a significant difference, particularly when the interest rate improvement is relatively small. Saving a few hundred dollars in interest each year might not be worthwhile if changing lenders costs several thousand dollars. It's also worth remembering that the cheapest loan on paper isn't necessarily the most suitable. Features such as offset accounts, redraw facilities and repayment flexibility may be just as important, depending on your circumstances.
Ultimately, refinancing should be about improving your overall financial position, not simply chasing the lowest advertised interest rate.
Is Refinancing Actually Worth It for You?
The answer depends on your circumstances, your current loan and what you're hoping to achieve. If your main priority is reducing monthly commitments, a longer loan term might be a perfectly reasonable option. If you're focused on paying off your mortgage sooner, maintaining your remaining loan term or making additional repayments might be more appropriate.
The important thing is understanding what you're gaining, what it costs and whether the change genuinely puts you in a better position.
That's also why I've included a Loan Comparison Calculator on the Your Home Loan Guy website. Rather than simply comparing interest rates or monthly repayments, it helps you see the difference in interest costs, ongoing fees, outstanding loan balances and the potential financial benefit of refinancing. You can compare loans over one, two, three or five years, or look at the longer-term picture. It's a useful starting point if you're wondering whether your existing mortgage is still competitive.
And if you'd prefer someone to review your home loan properly, I'm always happy to have a look. Sometimes refinancing makes perfect sense, and other times staying exactly where you are is the better decision.
Because at the end of the day, finding a better home loan isn't necessarily about securing the lowest repayment. It's about making sure your mortgage is working for you, rather than the other way around.
General information only. This article does not consider your personal financial circumstances, objectives or needs. Actual repayments, interest savings and refinancing costs will depend on your lender, loan structure and individual circumstances.




Comments